Mike's Creamy Potato Egg Salad

Source : Here S The Bulk Of What You Ll Need In Steps 1 And 2 Additional Ingredients Needed Rinse Unpeeled Baby Potatoes Well Place In Large Pot And Boil For ...

PreTime
more Minutes
CookTime
a few Minutes
Yield
Some Servings

Sent by

at : May 26, 2026

Step:

  1. Here's the bulk of what you'll need in steps #1 and #2.

    Mike's Creamy Potato Egg Salad recipe step 1 photo
  2. Additional ingredients needed.

    Mike's Creamy Potato Egg Salad recipe step 2 photo
  3. Rinse unpeeled baby potatoes well. Place in large pot and boil for 10 to 13 minutes.

    Mike's Creamy Potato Egg Salad recipe step 3 photo
  4. Boil your eggs by bringing room temp eggs to a steady boil. Turn off burner, cover pot and allow eggs to sit undisturbed for 18 minutes. At 18 minutes, immediately rinse your eggs in cold water to arrest the cooking process. About 10 minutes. Refill your pot with fresh cold water if needed. If any egg floats, throw it away.

    Mike's Creamy Potato Egg Salad recipe step 4 photo
  5. Drain your potatoes and allow them to cool a bit.

    Mike's Creamy Potato Egg Salad recipe step 5 photo
  6. Once cooled, slice all potatoes in half. Place in a large pot and again, allow to cool longer.

    Mike's Creamy Potato Egg Salad recipe step 6 photo
  7. In the meantime, chop your chilled vegetables and mix together well.

    Mike's Creamy Potato Egg Salad recipe step 7 photo
  8. Quite possibly the best chilled dill pickle brand ever! Definitely worth your money and seriously makes this dish! This is the only brand I'll ever use. In fact, if I don't have them on hand, I won't make the recipe it calls for.

    Mike's Creamy Potato Egg Salad recipe step 8 photo
  9. Peel and quarter your eggs. Allow them to cool covered.

    Mike's Creamy Potato Egg Salad recipe step 9 photo
  10. Gently mix all chopped vegetables and cooled eggs together.

    Mike's Creamy Potato Egg Salad recipe step 10 photo
  11. Mix your chilled cream sauce. Whisk well.

    Mike's Creamy Potato Egg Salad recipe step 11 photo
  12. Gently fold everything together in an extra large bowl. Refrigerate for 6 hours or longer stirring occasionally. I'll let mine sit for 24 hours.

    Mike's Creamy Potato Egg Salad recipe step 12 photo
  13. Garnish with fresh chives. Enjoy!

    Mike's Creamy Potato Egg Salad recipe step 13 photo

Ingredients

  1. ● For The Proteins
  2. 18 Egglands Best Eggs [use older eggs - they're easier to peel]
  3. ● For The Potatoes
  4. 3 Pounds Baby Creamer Potatoes [both red & white - left whole]
  5. ● For The Fresh Vegetables [all chilled & rough chopped]
  6. 1 EX LG Vidalia Onion
  7. 2 Green Onion Lengths [+ reserves for garnish]
  8. 1/3 Cup Red Onions
  9. 4 Stalks Celery [with leaves]
  10. 8 LG Claussens Dill Pickles [found in MKT refrigerated section]
  11. 1 Can LG Black Olives [halved]
  12. 1/3 Cup Fresh Parsley Leaves
  13. ● For The Cream Sauce [whisk well]
  14. 1 (30 oz) Jar Kraft Real Mayonnaise
  15. 1/2 tsp Fresh Ground Black Pepper
  16. 1/3 Cup Fresh Sour Cream
  17. 2 tbsp Yellow Mustard
  18. 1 1/4 Cup Whole Milk [more if needed]
  19. 1 tsp Celery Seed
  20. 1 tsp Celery Salt

Related Recipes

Mikes Classic Lobster Rolls

Mikes Classic Lobster Rolls

Mikes Clove Roasted Garlic Spread

Mikes Clove Roasted Garlic Spread

Mikes Chilly Greek Pita Salad

Mikes Chilly Greek Pita Salad

Mikes Chilled Greek Feta Salad

Mikes Chilled Greek Feta Salad

Mikes Garlic Lemon Herbed Chicken

Mikes Garlic Lemon Herbed Chicken

Mikes Black Pepper Bison  Garlic Russets On Sea Salt Bricks

Mikes Black Pepper Bison Garlic Russets On Sea Salt Bricks

Mikes Garlic Sriracha Chicken Scewers

Mikes Garlic Sriracha Chicken Scewers

Mikes Southwestern Patty Melts

Mikes Southwestern Patty Melts