Mike's Old Fashion Potato Egg Salad

Source : Here S What You Ll Need Rinse And Scrub Your Potatoes Well Bring Your Older Eggs To A Rolling Boil Turn Off Heat And Cover Eggs With A Tight Fitting ...

PreTime
more Minutes
CookTime
a few Minutes
Yield
Some Servings

Sent by

at : April 13, 2026

Step:

  1. Here's what you'll need.

    Mike's Old Fashion Potato Egg Salad recipe step 1 photo
  2. Rinse and scrub your potatoes well.

    Mike's Old Fashion Potato Egg Salad recipe step 2 photo
  3. Bring your [older] eggs to a rolling boil. Turn off heat and cover eggs with a tight fitting lid. Let eggs rest in hot water for 18 minutes.

    Mike's Old Fashion Potato Egg Salad recipe step 3 photo
  4. Place potatoes in water and boil for 25 to 30 minutes. When a knife can easily penetrate your largest potato - you'll know they're ready.

    Mike's Old Fashion Potato Egg Salad recipe step 4 photo
  5. Allow potatoes to cool in sink.

    Mike's Old Fashion Potato Egg Salad recipe step 5 photo
  6. Rinse in cold water immediately to arrest the cooking process.

    Mike's Old Fashion Potato Egg Salad recipe step 6 photo
  7. Peel eggs and seperate your yolks from your whites. Chop egg whites in to quarters and place in fridge.

    Mike's Old Fashion Potato Egg Salad recipe step 7 photo
  8. Mash your egg yolks.

    Mike's Old Fashion Potato Egg Salad recipe step 8 photo
  9. Add everything in the Cream Sauce section. Mix well with a whisk and refrigerate sauce.

    Mike's Old Fashion Potato Egg Salad recipe step 9 photo
  10. Chop potatoes into 1" cubes.

    Mike's Old Fashion Potato Egg Salad recipe step 10 photo
  11. Chop all of your vegetables and mix well. Consistently pre-mixing along the way will help you out greatly upon your final mix with your super messy cream sauce.

    Mike's Old Fashion Potato Egg Salad recipe step 11 photo
  12. Add your chopped egg whites and mix well again.

    Mike's Old Fashion Potato Egg Salad recipe step 12 photo
  13. Equally devide vegetables and solid egg whites in to 2 separate large bowls a this recipe will make a large batch. Mix well again.

    Mike's Old Fashion Potato Egg Salad recipe step 13 photo
  14. Equally devide potatoes in to each bowl and mix well.

    Mike's Old Fashion Potato Egg Salad recipe step 14 photo
  15. Equally devide your sauce mixture in to each bowl. Gently mix/fold from the base of bowls as to not break up your potatoes.

    Mike's Old Fashion Potato Egg Salad recipe step 15 photo
  16. Refrigerate and gentry stir occasionally. Let salad rest overnight in fridge for best results. Before serving - dash salad with Paprika and Celery Salt.

    Mike's Old Fashion Potato Egg Salad recipe step 16 photo
  17. Enjoy!

    Mike's Old Fashion Potato Egg Salad recipe step 17 photo

Ingredients

  1. 1 (5 Pound) Bag Idaho Russet Potatoes [peels left on]
  2. ● For The Proteins
  3. 25 LG Egglands Best Eggs [use older eggs - easier to peel]
  4. ● For The Cream Sauce
  5. 1 (30 oz) Bottle Kraft Mayonnaise
  6. 1-1 1/2 Cups Whole Milk [or, to your desired thickness]
  7. 1 1/2 tbsp Yellow Mustard
  8. 1 1/2 tbsp Granulated Sugar
  9. 1 tsp Celery Seed
  10. 1/2 tsp Celery Salt
  11. 1/2 tsp Fresh Ground Black Pepper
  12. ● For The Vegetables
  13. 1 Cup Celery With Leaves [chopped]
  14. 1 Jar Clausens Dill Pickles [be sure to use this brand - found i
  15. 2 Cans LG Black Olives [drained - cut in half]
  16. 3 LG White Onions [rough chop]
  17. 1/2 Cup Fresh Parsley

Related Recipes

Mikes Gilroy Garlic French Fries

Mikes Gilroy Garlic French Fries

Mikes Strawberry Banana Pineapple Compote

Mikes Strawberry Banana Pineapple Compote

Mikes Spicy Thai Chicken Rice Noodle Soup

Mikes Spicy Thai Chicken Rice Noodle Soup

Mikes Negima Yakitori

Mikes Negima Yakitori

Mikes Perfect Patty Melts

Mikes Perfect Patty Melts

Mikes Garlic Swiss Burgers

Mikes Garlic Swiss Burgers

Mikes Steak Cheese Onion  Mushroom Man-wich

Mikes Steak Cheese Onion Mushroom Man-wich

Mikes Chunky Chicken Fajita Style Soft Tacos

Mikes Chunky Chicken Fajita Style Soft Tacos