Mike's Perfect Baked Potatoes

Source : Preheat Your Oven To 400 Clean And Chop Vegetables Of Your Choosing Cover And Refrigerate Fully Clean And Fully Dry Your Idaho 1 Grade Potatoes With...

PreTime
more Minutes
CookTime
a few Minutes
Yield
Some Servings

Sent by

at : November 14, 2026

Step:

  1. Preheat your oven to 400°.

  2. Clean and chop vegetables of your choosing. Cover and refrigerate.

  3. Fully clean and fully dry your Idaho #1 grade potatoes.

    Mike's Perfect Baked Potatoes recipe step 3 photo
  4. With a sharp knife - peirce your spuds three times at both ends and once in the middle. Or, you can use a fork to peirce them.

    Mike's Perfect Baked Potatoes recipe step 4 photo
  5. Place your spuds on a large piece of tinfoil. Shiney side up.

  6. Smear your potatoes generously with cold bacon grease. Place back on tinfoil. You can use olive oil but, bacon grease definitely makes these better!

    Mike's Perfect Baked Potatoes recipe step 6 photo
  7. Sprinkle fresh cracked black pepper, sea salt, garlic powder and onion powder to taste on both sides of your bacon greased potatoes. I tend to go heavy on the sea salt! These are big spuds!

    Mike's Perfect Baked Potatoes recipe step 7 photo
  8. Wrap your potatoes up tightly.

    Mike's Perfect Baked Potatoes recipe step 8 photo
  9. Double wrap your potatoes tightly in another sheet of tinfoil. Again, shiney side up. A double wrap is more steak house style and steams your spuds more evenly.

    Mike's Perfect Baked Potatoes recipe step 9 photo
  10. Place potatoes seam side up on the center rack and place a cookie sheet on the rack underneath it to catch any potential drippings.

    Mike's Perfect Baked Potatoes recipe step 10 photo
  11. ● Bake for 1 1/2 hours. After that, gently peirce potatoes with a sharp knife in the center where you'll eventually slice your potatoes open. If the knife enters with ease - you'll know they're fully baked. If not, bake a bit longer until soft. ● Know that if you're baking more than 2 large potatoes - you'll need to increase your baking time by approximately 15 minutes.

  12. ● Once fully baked - you'll have two options. You can either serve by slitting the tinfoil and potato - then squeezing both ends together to force the moist insides up and out. Fluff with fork. Serve immediately with toppers of your guests choosing. ● Or, you can do the exact same thing but, gently scoop out the insides with a large spoon leaving your shells fully in tact. Place all insides quickly in a bowl, mix in all of your toppers in and, gently place back into your potato shells. You may need to re-heat mixture [not tinfoil] in the microwave before plating. Garnish with fresh chives and parsley. Enjoy!

    Mike's Perfect Baked Potatoes recipe step 12 photo

Ingredients

  1. Basic Potatoes
  2. 2 Extra Large Idaho #1 Grade Potatoes [1+ pound a piece - choose fresh/firm potatoes without deep brown spots]
  3. Chilled Bacon Grease
  4. Fresh Cracked Black Pepper
  5. Garlic Powder
  6. Onion Powder
  7. Sea Salt
  8. 4 large Sheets Tinfoil
  9. Potato Toppers
  10. Salted Butter
  11. Shreadded Cheddar Cheese
  12. Fresh Sour Cream
  13. Fresh Parsley [chopped]
  14. Fresh Chives [chopped]
  15. Chopped Crispy Bacon Or Bacon Bits [optional]

Related Recipes

Mikes Soft Boiled Egg VietnameseBanhMi Sandwiches

Mikes Soft Boiled Egg VietnameseBanhMi Sandwiches

Mikes BBQ Pulled Pork  Chicken Sandwiches

Mikes BBQ Pulled Pork Chicken Sandwiches

Mikes EZ Chicken  Dumplings

Mikes EZ Chicken Dumplings

Mikes Wasatch Caesar Salad

Mikes Wasatch Caesar Salad

Mikes Tangy Garden Fresh Summer Salad

Mikes Tangy Garden Fresh Summer Salad

Mikes Chinese Hot And Sour Soup

Mikes Chinese Hot And Sour Soup

Mikes Easy Cheesy Fried Burritos

Mikes Easy Cheesy Fried Burritos

Mikes Adult Lemon Lime Slushies

Mikes Adult Lemon Lime Slushies